Mercedes-Benz X-Class vs Volkswagen Amarok

When choosing a used premium pick-up, the Mercedes-Benz X-Class and the Volkswagen Amarok are two models often considered. Both offer a strong balance between everyday usability and capability, while delivering comfortable interiors and practical features. For anyone looking at the used market, understanding the key differences between these two vehicles can help make a more informed choice.

Engines and Performance

Both the X-Class and the Amarok come equipped with a 3.0-litre V6 diesel engine. In terms of power output, they are closely matched. The Mercedes-Benz X-Class produces 254bhp with 550Nm of torque, while the Volkswagen Amarok also offers 254bhp but slightly more torque at 580Nm.

This difference in torque gives the Amarok a small advantage in responsiveness, especially when carrying heavy loads or towing. The Amarok manages 0-60mph in around 7.0 seconds, while the X-Class is only slightly slower, achieving the same sprint in 7.5 seconds.

Both vehicles feature permanent four-wheel drive, ensuring solid traction in a range of conditions, whether on wet roads or more challenging off-road surfaces. Transmission differs slightly between the two, with the X-Class fitted with a seven-speed automatic gearbox and the Amarok using an eight-speed automatic. The Amarok’s additional gear ratio offers a marginal benefit to cruising comfort and fuel efficiency.

Top speeds are identical at 127mph, which is more than sufficient for motorway driving or longer commutes. In day-to-day use, either vehicle is more than capable of delivering the necessary performance for both work and leisure.

Fuel Economy and Emissions

Fuel economy is an important factor for many used pick-up buyers, particularly for those using the vehicle for both personal and professional purposes.

The Amarok edges ahead slightly in terms of economy, returning an average of 27.0mpg in testing, compared to the X-Class’s 27.2mpg. Although this is a very small difference, over long distances it could result in modest fuel savings.

When it comes to emissions, the Amarok again has a slight advantage, emitting 220g/km of CO₂ compared to the X-Class’s 236g/km. Although both vehicles attract similar annual road tax costs (around £240), lower emissions may be of interest to businesses mindful of environmental impact or operating in areas with stricter regulations.

Practicality and Driving Experience

Both the Mercedes-Benz X-Class and the Volkswagen Amarok are capable workhorses that combine strength with comfort.

The four-wheel drive systems in each model deliver excellent off-road capability, with features such as hill descent control and multiple driving modes in some examples. On-road, both provide a smooth ride for a pick-up, although buyers should be aware that these vehicles, by their nature, prioritise durability and strength over the soft ride quality of typical passenger cars.

The Amarok’s eight-speed gearbox contributes to a slightly more relaxed motorway cruising experience, with lower engine revs at higher speeds. However, the X-Class is not far behind and still offers a composed and capable drive.

Interior and Features

Interior quality is a strong point for both vehicles, especially compared to more utilitarian pick-ups. However, there are differences depending on the specification of the used vehicle being considered.

Many X-Class examples come well equipped, but often feature additional options that were fitted when new. These might include metallic paint, COMAND Online Navigation, black leather seats, a roll-top cover, and even a tow bar. As a result, used X-Class models vary considerably in specification and equipment levels. Buyers looking for specific features should carefully review individual vehicle listings.

The Amarok Aventura models come with a more standardised specification, including the Aventura-specific style pack with metallic paint. While options are more limited compared to the X-Class, this means there is usually less variation between used examples. In many cases, buyers can expect leather seats, navigation, parking sensors, and a range of comfort features as standard.

Ownership Considerations

When buying used, factors such as maintenance history, mileage, and overall condition are crucial. Both the X-Class and Amarok are generally reliable when properly maintained, although costs for servicing and repairs may be higher than for smaller, more basic vehicles.

Parts and servicing for the Amarok tend to be slightly more affordable due to Volkswagen’s broader dealer network and parts availability. However, Mercedes-Benz's aftersales service and strong brand reputation may appeal to those prioritising support and residual value.

It is also worth noting that while the Amarok and X-Class are both well-built, individual vehicles’ condition will vary depending on previous use. Some examples may have seen hard working lives, particularly in construction or farming, so careful inspection is advised.

Both the Mercedes-Benz X-Class and the Volkswagen Amarok represent strong choices in the used premium pick-up market. The Amarok offers slightly better fuel economy, lower emissions, and a more standardised set of features. Meanwhile, the X-Class provides greater scope for individualisation and maintains a distinct image associated with the Mercedes-Benz brand.

Ultimately, the best choice will depend on your personal needs, budget, and preference for features. Both vehicles are capable, durable, and offer a practical combination of everyday usability and off-road readiness. Browse our full range of Used Mercedes-Benz Vans & Volkswagen Vans for sale online.